| Member | Since |
| Amelia Payson House |
December, 1996 |
| Arbor House Bed & Breakfast |
April, 2003 |
| Bulfinch House Bed and Breakfast |
November, 2004 |
| Caffe Graziani |
March, 1997 |
| Cap'n Jack's Waterfront Inn |
September, 2004 |
| Capt.'s Waterfront Grill & Club |
August, 2007 |
| Coach House Inn |
April, 1997 |
| Corner Inn, Old |
April, 2000 |
| Cornerstone Books |
June, 2006 |
| Derby Square Tours |
January, 1998 |
| Destination Salem |
January, 2008 |
| Fame |
September, 2003 |
| Festival of the Dead |
April, 2003 |
| Friendship Carriage Tours |
December, 2005 |
| Grapevine Restaurant |
June, 1999 |
| Hamilton Hall |
February, 1998 |
| Henry Derby Boutique |
March, 2003 |
| Henry Derby Flowers |
March, 2003 |
| Henry Derby House |
March, 2003 |
| Lyceum Bar and Grill |
January, 2008 |
| Morning Glory Bed & Breakfast |
December, 1997 |
| Nathaniel's |
November, 1999 |
| New England Pirate Museum |
December, 1996 |
| Northey Street House |
January, 2003 |
| Phillips House |
September, 1998 |
| Salem Strolls |
May, 2004 |
| Salem Witch Museum |
June, 1996 |
| Stepping Stone Inn |
May, 1998 |
| Tavern at the Hawthorne |
November, 1999 |
| The Salem Inn |
March, 1996 |
| The Trolley Depot |
February, 1998 |
| The Tuck Inn Bed & Breakfast |
October, 2005 |
| Wicked Goodz |
May, 2008 |
| Witch Dungeon Museum |
December, 1996 |
| Witch History Museum |
December, 2001 |